
Do you feel bad after an extra piece of cake or do you feel like you have to ban yourself from eating for the next few days to “make up for it”? We’ll explain here what you can do about these feelings.
Many people are no stranger to feelings of guilt when eating. The guilty conscience after a piece of chocolate in between or the separation of foods into “good” and “bad” are spread daily on social media, but also in everyday life. Anyone who eats a salad is considered disciplined. Anyone who treats themselves to something sweet instead has “sinned”.
Why feelings of guilt when eating can be problematic

Widespread views about food, diets and supposedly healthy eating contribute to the fact that we view certain eating habits as not only healthier, but also morally better than others. Anyone who allows themselves something sweet every now and then is quickly seen as “undisciplined”. Conversely, your own discipline is emphasized when you live strictly according to a diet plan. Seemingly harmless statements such as “Today I controlled myself and didn’t eat cake” or “I have to work that off again tomorrow” can contribute to associating food with guilt and shame.
In an article for the online magazine Psyche, clinical psychologist Vivienne Lewis describes how such social messages normalize food guilt, i.e. feelings of guilt around eating. This becomes particularly problematic when eating and certain habits that go with it become increasingly linked to reward and punishment.
The National Eating Disorder Association (NEDA) lists rigid eating rules and feelings of guilt when not following them as possible signs of disordered eating behavior. Even if not every guilty conscience when eating is a sign of an eating disorder, it can put unnecessary stress on you in everyday life. We’ll give you some tips on what you can do to combat the feeling of guilt when eating.
1. Don’t divide food into “good” and “bad”

In Psyche magazine, psychologist Vivienne Lewis explains that an important step towards more calmness when eating is not to judge food morally. An occasional piece of chocolate isn’t bad just because it’s high in sugar. Likewise, a meal is not inherently good for your body because it consists of a salad. What matters more is what your diet looks like overall.
Of course, it makes sense to regularly eat foods that provide your body with nutrients, vitamins and minerals. But that doesn’t mean that your health will be harmed if you eat something sweet or seemingly “unhealthy” every now and then. Because enjoyment is also part of a balanced diet. Treating yourself occasionally doesn’t mean you have to feel guilty about it or restrict your other eating habits.
According to the NEDA, constantly evaluating food and categorizing it into “good” and “bad” can also be a possible sign of a disturbed relationship with food.
2. Question your feelings of guilt instead of judging yourself for them

If you regularly feel guilty about eating, you should try taking a closer look at your own thoughts:
- Where does the feeling of having done something wrong by snacking come from?
- Is it your own belief behind it or is it more of an idea that came about through diets, social ideals of beauty or comments from other people?
- Were your parents perhaps instilling certain views on food in you?
- Are you generally a perfectionist and like to optimize all processes, including your eating habits?
Clinical psychologist Vivienne Lewis recommends consciously questioning negative beliefs surrounding food and being gentler with yourself when exploring them. If you find that these beliefs do not fit the relationship you want to have with food, you can then work specifically on them and rewrite the associated rules and thoughts.
For example: Instead of saying to yourself after eating, “I shouldn’t have eaten that,” you can replace the thought with a neutral assessment: “I wanted it and enjoyed it. That’s okay.”
It is important not to punish yourself for deviating from your own nutritional ideas. A single snack says nothing about how balanced and therefore healthy your diet is overall.
3. Listen to your hunger and satiety

Fixed meal times are part of everyday life for many of us. Some people feel guilty if they eat something outside of these times. It’s completely normal that you sometimes get hungry in the morning or crave something sweet after dinner.
If you feel guilty about this, it can help you to pay more attention to your own body signals instead of following external rules around food. The Bavarian consumer portal recommends consciously focusing on feelings of hunger and satiety when eating.
Mindful eating can also help: If you really notice the taste, smell and consistency, you experience the meal more consciously and can better recognize when you are full.
- Don’t intentionally delay your hunger just because it’s not yet time for your next meal. If you have physical hunger signals (an empty feeling in your stomach or a rumbling stomach), this is definitely a sign that you should eat something.
- If you don’t feel such signals, maybe you just want to eat something out of boredom?
- Sometimes we continue to eat even though we are actually full – for example because we were taught in childhood that our plate always has to be empty.
- Instead of listening to external rules, you should also listen to your body on this point: If you are full, you don’t have to eat any more. Conversely, you can get seconds if you are really still hungry.
Barmer explains that such an intuitive way of eating is associated with less stress around food. Intuitive eating can also help you keep your weight stable in the long term.
Tip: Part of being aware of a meal is not constantly distracting yourself. Experience has shown that people who are always on their cell phones or watching TV while eating have little idea when they are really full.
4. Consciously allow yourself moments of pleasure

If you completely forbid yourself seemingly unhealthy things, that doesn’t make them any less tempting. On the contrary: strict bans often only make you want to eat the “forbidden” foods even more. Your thoughts then increasingly revolve around dishes and snacks that you “shouldn’t eat under any circumstances”. That’s why it can help to consciously allow yourself to eat “unhealthy” things just out of joy and not just out of hunger.
It is crucial that your usual diet contains enough nutrients and vitamins. If you eat a balanced diet every day, you can treat yourself to a piece of cake every now and then in the afternoon without having to compensate afterwards.
Lewis gives the tip to also pay attention to your social environment when eating: Negative conversations about diets, body weight and supposed eating sins can unnecessarily fuel feelings of guilt around the topic of food. Eating together should not be accompanied by justifications or comments. If you regularly eat with people who have these conversations, you should, if possible, reconsider your eating company.
Read more on Techzle\.com:
- Orthorexia, or: the fear of eating “wrong”.
- Dietary supplements – are they useful, unnecessary or even dangerous?
- Personalized nutrition: How useful are DNA diets, saliva tests and the like?
Independent journalism needs people who stand behind it – including in Google searches. Now send a signal for more sustainability and → Save Utopia as a preferred source.
** marked with ** or orange underlined Links to sources of supply are partly partner links: If you buy here, you are actively supporting Techzle\.com, because we then receive a small part of the sales proceeds. More info.